Our Progress

Duke Energy is closing all ash basins across our system, and we've made tremendous progress to accomplish this important work.

To meet that goal and comply with state and federal regulations, we holistically planned upgrades including dry ash handling systems, new wastewater treatment systems and new lined landfills. Thanks to this multiyear effort to engineer, design and construct systems to safely manage ash, plant process waters and stormwater, all new ash produced at our facilities today is being recycled or going to lined landfills.

Systemwide, more than 46 million tons of ash have been excavated to a lined landfill, properly closed in place or beneficially reused such as through recycling into concrete. As announced in January 2020, Duke Energy, state regulators and community groups agreed to a plan to permanently close the company's remaining nine coal ash basins in North Carolina.

Tables outlining North Carolina closure plans and progress as of the settlement date are below. A more recently updated table showing closure deadlines and progress for all ash basins systemwide, including our Indiana basins, can be seen here.

Aerial view of Duke Energy's Dan River site in May 2019.

North Carolina basin closure plans announced in January 2020

Plant	Basins already excavated	Basins remaining	Basin closure method	Ash to be excavated (million tons)	Excavated ash (m/tons)	Basin closure deadline²/actual
Allen		2	Excavation	19.36	0	December 2038
Belews Creek		1	Excavation	11.87	0	December 2034
Cliffside		2	Excavation	7.59	0	December 2029
Marshall		1	Excavation of uncapped ash	17.43	0	December 2035
Mayo		1	Excavation	6.63	0	December 2029
Roxboro		2	Excavation of uncapped ash	16.86	0	December 2036
Subtotal for basins addressed in the agreement		9		79.74	0

Previously announced North Carolina basin closure plans

Plant	Basins already excavated	Basins remaining	Basin closure method	Basin ash to be excavated (million tons)	Excavated ash (m/tons)	Closure deadline/actual
Asheville¹	1	1	Excavation	1.38	6.94	August 2022
Buck		3	Excavation for recycling	6.65	0	December 2035
Cape Fear		5	Excavation for recycling	5.77	0	December 2035
Cliffside¹	1	0	Excavation	0	0.46	March 2017
Dan River¹	2	0	Excavation	0	3.99	May 2019
H.F. Lee		4	Excavation for recycling	6.23	0	December 2035
Riverbend¹	2	0	Excavation	0	5.35	March 2019
Sutton¹	2	0	Excavation	0	7.19	July 2019
Weatherspoon		1	Excavation for recycling	1.68	0.47	April 2028
Subtotal for previously announced excavation	8	14		21.71	24.40
Total for North Carolina excavation	8	23		101.45	Grand total: 125.85

1. Pending regulator review of final closure, figures reflect the completed excavation of the Asheville 1982 Basin (fall 2016); Cliffside Inactive 1-4 Basin (spring 2017); Dan River primary and secondary basins (summer 2019), ash stack 1 and ash stack 2; Riverbend primary and secondary basins (spring 2019), structural fill and cinder pit; and Sutton 1971 and 1984 Basins (summer 2019).

2. Closure dates assume the company receives deadline extensions as outlined in settlement, and exclude post-closure monitoring/maintenance.

2020 Progess

Received regulatory approval of closure plans for all our remaining basins in North Carolina, including at the six sites in the agreement announced in January 2020.
Began operation of new ash recycling facilities at Buck and H.F. Lee, with another at Cape Fear expected to be running by year-end or early 2021. Once all three are operational, the company will have the capacity to recycle more coal ash than our power plants produce each year in the Carolinas.
Completed enclosure of the Dan River and Sutton lined landfills; ash at both sites has been fully excavated.
Started excavating ash at Buck and H.F. Lee (recycling) along with Cliffside and Marshall, where lined landfills are already situated to start accepting ash. Continued ash excavation at Weatherspoon – now about one-third complete – for recycling at South Carolina cement kilns.
Completed construction of a new lined landfill at Robinson in South Carolina; began construction of an on-site lined landfill at Asheville, where excavation will be completed in 2022; started construction of additional landfill cells at Cliffside.
Submitted a landfill permit modification at Marshall and permits to construct new on-site landfills at other North Carolina sites, along with W.S. Lee in South Carolina. In general, these lined landfills will start accepting ash about a year after we receive construction approval from the state regulatory agencies.
Safely completed bulk water removal (decanting) at all our North Carolina basins, a key first step in resolving groundwater impacts, and began implementing the pilot phase of our groundwater remediation systems at several sites.
In Indiana, closure work is complete on six basins, with 16 remaining and several others nearing completion. Progress continues through a combination of excavation and in-place closure, with the method driven by site-specific considerations at each basin:
- Cayuga – One basin excavated. Remaining: one by excavation, three by closure in place.
- Gallagher – Two basins excavated. Remaining: one by excavation, three by closure in place.*
- Gibson – Two basins excavated and one closed in place. Remaining: one by excavation, two by closure in place.*
- Wabash River – Remaining: three by excavation, two by closure in place.*
  * Several closure plans are still under state regulator review: Gallagher (one basin), Gibson (four basins), and Wabash River (two basins).

- Reached an agreement with North Carolina regulators and community groups to permanently close all remaining ash basins in North Carolina. The plan:
  
  Relies heavily on excavation with ash placed in lined landfills
  
  Lowers estimated closure cost by approximately $1.5 billion while ensuring that people, communities and environment are well-protected
  
  Resolves pending environmental litigation related to basin closure methods
- Completed the excavation of 12 ash basins, with nearly 28 million tons of ash moved to fully lined facilities or recycled.
- Completed ash basin excavation at three North Carolina facilities: Dan River Steam Station in Eden, Sutton Plant in Wilmington and Riverbend Steam Station in Mount Holly; additionally, completed excavation at East Bend Station in Kentucky and excavation of the second of three basins at W.S. Lee Steam Station in South Carolina.
- Construction well underway at three new coal ash recycling units at three plant sites in North Carolina to reprocess ash for use in the construction industry: Buck in Salisbury, H.F. Lee in Goldsboro and Cape Fear in Moncure. Once the units come online in 2020 and 2021, the company will recycle more ash than it produces each year.
- Completed ash handling technology upgrades at operating coal plants to take ash basins permanently out of service. This includes new dry ash handling systems, wastewater treatment and stormwater management systems. All production ash is now being handled dry in lined landfills or being recycled, with no ash going to basins (other than at Asheville and Gallagher, which are being retired).
- Ongoing removal of water from basins across the system, a necessary step regardless of the closure method.
- Received approval from the Indiana Department of Environmental Management for the closure and post-closure plans for several basins at Wabash River Station.
Strong Progress through 2018
- The scope and scale of the company's work to close 59 basins at 21 plants continues to move forward. Highlights of the progress include:
  More than 7 million work hours were logged in 2018 by expert teams focused on basin closure, demonstrating the company's commitment to safely managing coal ash.
- Work to prepare basins for closure is underway across the fleet. By mid-2019, the company will stop sending ash and wastewater to nearly all basins, in advance of state and federal requirements. To accomplish this, the company constructed dry bottom ash handling systems, lined water treatment basins and new lined retention basins at a number of operating coal plants.
- Ash has been excavated from seven basins at the Asheville Plant (Asheville, N.C.), Rogers Energy Complex (Mooresboro, N.C.), W.S. Lee facility (Belton, S.C.), Cayuga Generating Station (Cayuga, Ind.), Gibson Generating Station (Owensville, Ind.) and Gallagher Generating Station (New Albany, Ind.).
- In the coming months, excavation will be completed at seven additional basins at the Dan River facility (Eden, N.C.), Riverbend Steam Station (Mount Holly, N.C.), Sutton Energy Complex (Wilmington, N.C.) and East Bend Station (Boone Co., Ky.).
- Approximately 22 million tons of ash have been excavated since basin closure began in recent years, with more than 5 million tons moved in 2018 alone.
- A vital step in closure is to remove the free water from the basins, which will happen at both excavated and capped facilities. That process is underway at many locations and is the most effective step in improving groundwater quality. In addition, the company has begun work to determine additional corrective actions to improve groundwater, and it will monitor groundwater for decades to ensure that the environment remains well protected.
Third and Fourth Quarter 2018
- Completed two implosions to demolish the retired Buck Steam Station in Salisbury, N.C., as we move to cleaner energy sources. The first implosion was successfully completed in August, and then the remainder of the facility was imploded in October. The site is now home to a highly efficient natural gas plant.
- Completed demolition of Riverbend Steam Station in Mount Holly, N.C., and site grading is expected to conclude by the end of the year.
- Ash basins across the system, particularly near the North Carolina coast, weathered hurricanes Florence and Michael very well, thanks to planning and aggressive work to safely close coal ash basins.
- Strong progress was made to safely close the east ash pond at our Gibson plant in Indiana by safely capping the facility.
- Completed installation of permanent water supplies to North Carolina plant neighbors, giving them peace of mind in their future water supply and preserving the full range of basin closure options, benefiting all customers.
Second Quarter 2018

Completed permanent water supply projects for plant neighbors around the Cape Fear, H.F. Lee and Allen facilities and are more than 80 percent complete with projects across the state.

Completed the transition to dry bottom ash handling technology at the Belews Creek and Cliffside sites, meaning all ash there is now being managed in on-site, lined landfills.

Secured the necessary permits from state regulators to build a new coal ash recycling unit at the Buck plant in Salisbury. This is the first of three units to be constructed in North Carolina to reprocess coal ash for use in the construction industry. Already the company is recycling 70 percent of the ash it is producing.

Completed mechanical demolition of the retired Riverbend facility near Charlotte as part of ongoing work to modernize the energy mix that serves customers.

Shared this Lake Norman fact sheet with members of the community to address questions related to ash operations and lake water quality.

First Quarter 2018

Through May 2018, the company has excavated nearly 18 million tons of coal ash, relocating the material to lined storage or to be recycled for use in the construction industry. Work continues at four sites to permanently close ash basins through excavation.

Continued strong efforts to recycle coal ash. For example, across the fleet in 2017, about 70 percent of the ash generated in the production of electricity was reused.

Engineering and planning continue to safely close all of the company’s ash basins. Projects that will allow us to manage all ash dry will be completed by the end of this year. In addition, work continues on lined retention basins to redirect water flows at operating plant sites.

Demolition work is ongoing at a number of older, retired coal plants including Riverbend near Charlotte, which was featured in this report by WFAE.

Early 2018 saw an increase in visible activity related to the installation of permanent new water supplies for plant neighbors across the Carolinas. Work crews have been active in every eligible neighborhood installing new water lines or robust water filter systems.
Fourth Quarter 2017
- Continue to excavate ash from the Asheville Plant (Asheville, N.C.), Dan River Steam Station (Eden, N.C.), Riverbend Steam Station (Mount Holly, N.C.) and Sutton Plant (Wilmington, N.C.) to fully lined, permanent solutions.
- Preparation work continues for ash basin closure in the Midwest and Carolinas. This includes conversion projects that will allow us to manage all ash dry and the construction of new, lined retention basins to redirect water flows at operating plant sites.
- Continue installing permanent water solutions for North Carolina plant neighbors. This includes new water main and service line connections in some communities and whole-home water treatment systems in others.
- Continue retired coal-fired plant decommissioning and demolition projects at sites in the Carolinas and Midwest.
- Completed ash excavation project at W.S. Lee Station (Belton, S.C.) to a fully lined, permanent solution.
Third Quarter 2017
- Began permitting process for the ash reprocessing units at the Buck and H.F. Lee sites. Each unit will reprocess about 300,000 tons of ash annually to make it suitable for use in concrete products. Planning continues for the third unit at the Cape Fear site.
- Hosted community information session for Buck site reprocessing unit.
- Announced a new coal ash recycling project at the Weatherspoon site in Lumberton, N.C. The ash will be sent to cement kilns in South Carolina. This is an update to previous plans, which were to use the Weatherspoon ash in structural fills.
- Began installing permanent water solutions for North Carolina plant neighbors. This includes new water main and service line connections in some communities and whole-home water treatment systems in others.
Second Quarter 2017
- Announced plans to recycle coal ash from the basins at the Cape Fear Plant in Moncure, N.C. and safely recycle the valuable material for use in concrete products.
- Completed ash basin excavation project at the Rogers Energy Complex (Mooresboro, N.C.) to a fully lined, permanent solution.
- Hosted four community open houses for neighbors near our Indiana plants to learn more about our plans to safely close basins.
- Awarded $1.1 million in Water Resources Fund grants to improve local water quality.
First Quarter 2017
- Hosted information sessions for our North Carolina plant neighbors to learn more about permanent water plans.
- Received preliminary approval from the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (NCDEQ) of its plans to offer new, permanent water supplies to eligible neighbors near its North Carolina coal plants.
Fourth Quarter
- In 2016 alone, we safely moved over 5 million tons of coal ash to permanent solutions.
- Continue to excavate ash from the Asheville Plant (Asheville, N.C.), Rogers Energy Complex (Mooresboro, N.C.), Dan River Steam Station (Eden, N.C.), Riverbend Steam Station (Mount Holly, N.C.), Sutton Plant (Wilmington, N.C.) and W.S. Lee Steam Station (Belton, S.C.) to fully lined, permanent solutions.
- Announced plans to excavate coal ash from four basins at the H.F. Lee Plant in Goldsboro, N.C., and safely recycle the valuable material for use in concrete products.
- Announced community-specific recommendations to offer new, permanent drinking water supplies and financial supplements to neighbors near its coal ash basins in North Carolina.
- Made a $1 million investment in the Cape Fear, N.C., region to promote the ongoing quality and health of public waterways in the area.
- Posted proposed closure plans for 36 ash basins that are regulated by the federal Coal Combustion Residuals (CCR) rule.
- On-site landfill construction underway at Sutton Plant and Dan River Steam Station after receiving necessary permits from the state to begin.
- Implosion events to continue decommissioning work at the retired Sutton Plant and Dan River Station mark new milestones in Duke Energy's campaign to replace older, less-efficient plants with cleaner energy.
- Announced plans to remove coal ash from three basins at the Buck Steam Station and safely recycle the valuable material for concrete.
Third Quarter
- Crews at Riverbend Station have safely moved 100 trains, or more than 850,000 tons of coal ash to a fully lined structural fill at the Brickhaven Mine in Chatham County, N.C. Using trains to move coal ash has kept more than 47,000 trucks off of local roads and highways.
- Crews at Dan River have safely moved 100 trains, or more than 500,000 tons of coal ash to a fully lined landfill in Amelia County, Va. Using trains to move coal ash has kept more than 27,500 trucks off of local roads and highways.
- Crews at Sutton Plant have safely moved 100 trains, or more than 750,000 tons of coal ash to a fully lined structural fill at the Brickhaven Mine in Chatham County, N.C. Using trains to move coal ash has kept more than 40,000 trucks off of local roads and highways.
- Passage of House Bill 630 provides practical solutions to protect the public and the environment, while preserving the flexibility to safely close ash basins in ways that also protect our customers. We are working to meet the requirements of this new law, including providing permanent water solutions to plant neighbors.
Second Quarter
- Awarded $730,000 in Water Resources Fund grants to nine local organizations. In addition, we announced grants totaling $500,000 from the Water Resources Fund specifically for the Dan River region.
- Completed first two implosion events as part of the decommissioning of the retired Sutton Plant in Wilmington, N.C.
- Began dewatering process at H.F. Lee Plant (Goldsboro, N.C.) to safely close the 1984 basin.
First Quarter
- Began transporting coal ash from our Asheville Plant to the fully lined Cliffside landfill in Mooresboro, N.C.
- Began the dewatering process at Riverbend Steam Station, which will allow us to safely close the basin.
- Completed rail systems and began transporting coal ash by rail from Riverbend Steam Station and Sutton Plant to Brickhaven Mine
Fourth Quarter
- Announced proposed on-site landfill to manage remaining coal ash at W.S. Lee Steam Station in Belton, S.C.
- Started excavation project at Dan River Steam Station to remove coal ash by train and deliver to a fully lined landfill in Amelia County, Va.
- Began excavating coal ash at the Sutton Plant to the final storage solution at Brickhaven Mine in Chatham Co., N.C., a beneficial reuse project.
- Started delivering coal ash to the Brickhaven Mine in Chatham County, an engineered structural fill constructed to reclaim an existing clay mine on the site. Watch the video.
- Began excavating coal ash from an inactive basin at Cliffside Steam Station (Rogers Energy Complex) to an existing on-site landfill, with minimal impact to the neighbors.
- Imploded the historic Cliffside powerhouse as part of Duke Energy’s modernization effort.
Third Quarter
- Finalized a comprehensive $7 million settlement with NCDEQ (formerly NCDENR) that resolves former, current and future groundwater issues at all 14 North Carolina coal facilities, including the retired Sutton plant.
- North Carolina regulators tested private wells near coal ash basins and wells that are far enough removed from the basins to be unaffected by them. The results show constituents found in private well samples occur naturally at various levels across the state.
- Submitted comprehensive groundwater assessments to the N.C. Department of Environment and Natural Resources (NCDENR) for each of the 14 coal plants in the state.
- Announced that the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) will conduct a comprehensive study of the coal ash recycling market and available technologies.
- Announced demolition plan for retired stacks at Sutton Plant (Wilmington, N.C.).
- Received the draft wastewater and stormwater permits for Sutton Plant (Wilmington, N.C.) and other facilities in the Carolinas.
Second Quarter
- Recommended excavating five basins at the Cape Fear Plant (Moncure, N.C.), five basins at H.F. Lee Plant (Goldsboro, N.C.), one basin at W.H. Weatherspoon Plant (Lumberton, N.C.), and one inactive basin at the Cliffside Steam Station (Mooresboro, N.C.). Read more.
- North Carolina regulators issued necessary permits to Charah Inc., a vendor engaged in closing ash basins, and its subsidiary, Green Meadow LLC, for structural fill projects at clay mines in Lee and Chatham counties in North Carolina.
- Began coal ash excavation at Riverbend Steam Station (Mount Holly, N.C.) to a fully lined landfill.
- Announced plans to retire the coal-fired Asheville Plant (Asheville, N.C.) in four to five years and modernize our generation and transmission system in western North Carolina and upstate South Carolina – significantly reducing environmental impacts, improving system reliability and minimizing long-term costs to customers. Read more
- Began first phase of excavation at W.S. Lee Steam Station (Belton, S.C.), relocating about 1.4 million tons of ash from the inactive ash basin and an ash fill area to a lined landfill in Homer, Ga.
- North Carolina regulators issued the final industrial stormwater permits for the Allen (Belmont, N.C.), Marshall (Terrell, N.C.) and Riverbend (Mount Holly, N.C.) stations.
- Announced coal ash from the Robinson Plant (Hartsville, S.C.) will be excavated and relocated to an on-site, lined landfill, completing the comprehensive strategy for the two South Carolina coal facilities. Read more
- Announced plans to build fully lined on-site landfills at the Dan River Steam Station (Eden, N.C.) and the Sutton Plant (Wilmington, N.C.).
First Quarter
- Research from universities, regulators and industry experts increasingly demonstrate that the Dan River is in good condition one year after a coal ash spill at the Dan River Steam Station.
Fourth Quarter
- Submitted filings to state regulators outlining additional ash excavation plans for W.S. Lee Steam Station in Belton, S.C.
- Submitted detailed coal ash excavation plans to the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (NCDENR) for ash stored at the high-priority Asheville Steam Electric Plant (Asheville, N.C.), Dan River Steam Station (Eden, N.C.), Riverbend Steam Station (Mount Holly, N.C.) and L.V. Sutton Steam Electric Plant (Wilmington, N.C.) facilities. Read more.
- Announced plans to enhance coal ash management operations with the creation of a national panel of independent experts to help guide the company’s strategy around permanent coal ash storage solutions and a new, centralized internal organization to manage all coal combustion products, including coal ash.
Third Quarter
- Announced the creation of a $10 million Water Resources Fund to benefit waterways across North Carolina and South Carolina. The fund can also be used to improve waterways downstream from Duke Energy operations that flow into neighboring states.
- Announced plans to excavate a portion of coal ash at the W.S. Lee Steam Station (Belton, S.C.), while continuing engineering work on the rest of the site. Read more.
- Completed cleanup work along the Dan River just upstream of the Schoolfield Dam in Danville, Va., under the direction of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
Second Quarter
- Completed ash basin-related pipe inspections at North Carolina coal plants and shared those results with NCDENR.
First Quarter
- Dan River water quality returned to normal and drinking water remained safe. Read more.

North Carolina basin closure plans announced in January 2020

Previously announced North Carolina basin closure plans

2020 Progess

2019 Progress

2018 Progress

2017 Progress

2016 Progress

2015 Progress

2014 Progress